How to Make Pro Cream Cheese Icing

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

If you’re an avid baker like me, or not, it’s essential to have a yummy light icing recipe on hand. My Cream Cheese Icing recipe is the kind that makes your taste buds do the crazy.

Other than it’s divine flavor, I love this recipe because it freezes well! I learned how to make this icing years ago from my aunt over the phone. Since then, I have taught my mother and quite a few other people how to make it. Now, I’m so happy to be sharing it with you!

Buckle up because we’re about to embark on a journey to create the best darn cream cheese icing you’ve ever tasted. No fancy bakery required, just a whole lot of love and a few simple ingredients.

easy cream cheese icing in a white bowl with decorative wooden dough roller on a white marble countertop

What You’ll Need to Make My Cream Cheese Icing

1. Cream Cheese – The Star of the Show

Start with a block of cream cheese. Make sure it’s softened to room temperature; we want it to play nice with the other ingredients. Cream cheese is the star of our show, adding that rich, velvety texture we all adore and a strong flavor profile that I’ll share below.

2. Butter – The Trusty Sidekick

Next up, a stick of butter. Not margarine, dear, real butter. Unsalted, please. It’s the trusty sidekick that gives our icing a delightful depth of flavor. Make sure it’s also softened – we’re aiming for a harmonious blend. (If you absolutely must, use a butter substitute but it won’t be the same.)

3. Confectioners Sugar – The Sweet Clouds

Here comes the magic dust – 3 to 4 cups of confectioners sugar. Sift it, my lovelies. Sift it like you’re creating sweet, sugary clouds. This is what will give our icing that perfect sweetness and help bind everything together.

4. Vanilla – The Elixir of Elegance

And now, the luscious touch – 3 to 4 tablespoons of vanilla. Don’t skimp on the good stuff; vanilla is the fragrance that ties the flavors together. It’s the secret ingredient that’ll have everyone asking, “What’s your secret?”

4 simple ingredients for cream cheese icing: cream cheese, butter, vanilla, and confectioners sugar (powdered sugar)

Cream Cheese Flavor Profile

Cream cheese has a rich and tangy flavor profile that adds a delightful complexity to creams and icings. Here’s how I would describe the flavor it brings to any dessert.

Richness: Cream cheese contributes a luxurious and velvety richness to creams and icings, making them indulgent and satisfying.
Tanginess: The signature tanginess of cream cheese provides a pleasant and slightly sharp contrast to the sweetness in creams and icings. It adds a zesty, lively kick to the overall flavor.
Creaminess: Cream cheese imparts a smooth and creamy texture, creating a luscious mouthfeel in icings. It adds a layer of decadence that enhances the overall dessert experience.
Depth: The flavor of cream cheese goes beyond mere sweetness, offering a depth that complements and balances the sugar. It brings a nuanced taste that elevates the entire dessert.
Subtle Saltiness: Cream cheese often has a subtle saltiness that enhances the overall flavor profile. This hint of saltiness can cut through the sweetness, creating a well-balanced taste.
Mild Cheesiness: While not overpowering, cream cheese does contribute a mild cheesiness that can be described as comforting and familiar. It adds a hint of savory notes to the sweet canvas.
Versatility: Cream cheese is incredibly versatile, adapting well to various flavor additions like vanilla, citrus, or chocolate. It acts as a versatile base, allowing for creative flavor combinations in icings and creams.

easy and creamy cream cheese icing in a white bowl

What Can I Use Cream Cheese Icing for?

This heavenly cream cheese icing is as versatile as they come! Here are a few delightful ways to use this sweet symphony in your kitchen:

Classic Cake and Pie Companion

Spread this luscious icing atop your favorite cakes and pies – be it a velvety red velvet, a moist carrot cake, key lime or chocolate mousse pie, or a simple vanilla delight. It’s the perfect partner for a classic slice of heaven.

Cupcake Crowning Glory

Transform ordinary cupcakes into extraordinary treats with a generous swirl of cream cheese icing. Add a sprinkle of love, and voila – you’ve got cupcakes fit for royalty!

Cookie Couture

Dress up your cookies in style! Smear a dollop of this creamy goodness on your sugar cookies or sandwich it between two for an extra delightful experience. It’s like a hug for your cookies.

Brownie Bliss

Take your brownies to the next level by slathering them with this decadent icing. The fudgy goodness of brownies paired with the creamy delight of the icing is a match made in dessert heaven.

Cinnamon Roll Sensation

Give your cinnamon rolls a makeover by generously drizzling them with cream cheese icing. The sweet, tangy notes perfectly complement the warm, spiced goodness of the rolls.

Pancake and Waffle Wow

Step up your breakfast game by topping pancakes or waffles with a generous spoonful of this icing. It’s an indulgent way to start your day – why wait for dessert?

Fruit Salad Surprise

Surprise your taste buds by mixing a bit of this icing into your fruit salad. It adds a sweet, tangy twist that elevates the entire dish. Grandma’s secret weapon for turning fruit into a treat!

Muffin Magic

Whether it’s blueberry, banana, or chocolate chip muffins, a swirl of cream cheese icing takes them from ordinary to extraordinary. It’s a delightful surprise hidden beneath the muffin tops.

Bagel Brilliance

Spread this velvety delight on a toasted bagel for a sweet morning treat. Add some fresh berries on top for an extra burst of flavor.

Cheesecake Charmer

As if cheesecake couldn’t get any better! Use this cream cheese icing as a topping for your cheesecake for an extra layer of creaminess. It’s the cherry on top of your cheesecake masterpiece.

easy how to make cream cheese icing in a white bowl with gold measuring spoons next to it

Important Tips on How to Best Make Cream Cheese Icing

Softened Ingredients

Take a moment, my dears, to ensure your cream cheese and butter are softened. This is the key to a smooth, harmonious blend. Leave them out at room temperature for a bit, or use the microwave in short bursts if you’re in a hurry. Cold ingredients lead to lumps, and we don’t want that.

Gradual Sugar Additions

When adding the confectioners sugar, do it gradually. Patience is a virtue, and in the world of cream cheese icing, it’s a necessity. This prevents sugar storms and ensures a silky-smooth texture. Sift as you go for an even fluffier result.

Taste as You Go

Don’t be afraid to taste as you go. Your palate knows best! Adjust the sweetness and vanilla to your liking. Some like it a bit more vanilla-y, and that’s perfectly fine. This icing is all about making it your own.

easy to make cream cheese icing in a white bowl surrounded by decorative cooking tools

FAQs (Because I Know What’s on Your Mind)

Can I use salted butter?

Stick with unsalted butter. Too much salt in the butter might throw off the delicate balance we’re aiming for.

My icing is too runny. What do I do?

Pop that bowl in the fridge for a spell. Chilling it will firm things up. If it’s still misbehaving, a gentle addition of more confectioners sugar should do the trick. Slow and steady wins the race.

Can I add cocoa for chocolate cream cheese icing?

Absolutely, add cocoa powder to taste for a chocolatey twist. Just remember to balance it with a touch more sugar to keep the sweetness in check.

My cream cheese icing is a culinary chameleon, ready to transform any dish into a sweet sensation. Get creative, experiment, and let your taste buds guide you on a delectable journey!

The keys to crafting the most heavenly cream cheese icing are now within your reach. With softened ingredients, a patient hand, and a few personalized touches, you’ll have a frosting that’ll make your bakes the talk of the town. So, get those mixers whirring and let the sweet symphony begin. Happy icing!

Great Dessert Options to Check Out: